There's a long-standing debate about what happens when an engagement is called off: Who should get to keep the ring?

After a Reddit user shared a photo of a wedding ring they found in their yard, internet users had a variety of theories as to how it got there.

Settino has said the man was just a friend. Johnson ended the engagement ... the justices said the case raised the question ...

A man who purchased a ring for an extravagant $70,000 will be getting it back from his ex-fiancée after breaking off the ...

A Massachusetts court ruled that a man is entitled to the return of a $70,000 engagement ring he gave his former fiancée. The ...

Massachusetts’ highest court reversed a longstanding ruling, saying an engagement ring must be returned if the wedding falls ...

Massachusetts has overruled a six-decade ruling that engagement rings are returned to the offended party in a former coupling ...

A groom called off his wedding after the bride demanded he buy her a more expensive ring. 'A price tag on a shiny mineral ...

Settino has said the man was just a friend. Johnson ended the engagement ... the case raised the question of whether the ...

Settino claimed the other man in question was a lifelong friend and nothing more, and a lower court later agreed with her. But Johnson didn't believe her and canceled the wedding. Popping the question ...