Subway announced the return of popular footlong cookies with the release of an Oreo-inspired footlong, released Thursday.

But why wait for a special occasion to enjoy this classic duo? These chocolate mint sandwich cookies are the perfect way to indulge in that rich, fudgy flavor balanced by a refreshing mint cream.

We compared chocolate chip cookies from five popular chains to see ... smelled — it reminded us of the chain's Italian sandwich bread. Needless to say, that's not what we're looking for in ...

Subway made the Oreo footlong cookie available to buy in Michigan Thursday. The cookie will be available for a limited time. Subway first rolled out the footlong cookie concept with the chocolate chip ...

"It’s caramelized on top, insanely gooey in the center and chewy on the edges," says the chef-owner of Milk Bar bakeries Sabrina Weiss is the Editorial Assistant of PEOPLE's food department.